Skip to main content ↑ ↓
Topic: Best player taken per round 2017-2022 minor league drafts (Read 3312 times) previous topic - next topic

Best player taken per round 2017-2022 minor league drafts

I waived my 2022 1st round pick a couple of days ago. Made me realize I suck at drafting players. Brent also made a comment about a 10th round future all-star.........so I went back to the drafts that are still available on the forum page and found the best player for each round in the past drafts. (I used whatever WAR number I found usually)
2017:
RD.pick:
15.4 Luis Arrez- River City
14.13 Zac Gallen- Data City (reluctantly after missing out on Shed Long)
13.5  Adolis Garcia- Brooklyn
12.15 Gavin Lux- Anecky
11.12 Will Smith- Arizona Asterisks
10.15 T.J Freidl- Anecky
9.1  Randy Arozarena- Arizona Asterisks
8.6  Shane Beiber- Scurvy Dogs
7.16 Andres Giminez- Foothill
6.1  Lourdes Guriel- Bronxville
5.6  Yordan Alvarez- Barbuda
4.13 Corbin Burns- Data City
3.13 Austin Hays- Data City
2.2 Matt Chapman- Wala Wala
1.15 Juan Soto- Anecky
Earliest bad pick:  1.1 Brendan McKay- Bronxville
2018 
RD.pick:  
12.16 Cole Irvin- Arizona Asterisks
10.6  Will Benson- Motor City
9.16 Tony Gonsolin- Arizona Asterisks
8.14 Jeff McNeil- Wala Wala
7.14 Julio Rodriguez- Foothill
6.16 Cedrick Mullins- Phoenix Miners
5.18 Isaac Paredes- Brooklyn
4.15 Luis Regnifo- Lakeview
3.17 William Contreras- Data City
2.11 Shane Mcclanahan- Bako
1.16 Peter Alonso- Arizona Asterisks
Earliest bad pick:  1.8 Julio Pablo Martinez -Phoenix Miners
2019
7.19 Gabriel Moreno- Ann Arbor
6.5 Geraldo Perdomo- Phoenix Miners
5.7 Justin Steele- River City
4.4 Jared Duran- Motor City
3.19 Gunnar Henderson- Grants Pass
2.13 George Kirby- Scurvy Dogs
1.2 Bobby Whitt jr- Bako Bums
Earliest bad pick 1.11 Hunter Bishop- Phoenix Miners
2021
14.13 Colby Mayo- Arizona Koi
13.17 Bailey Falter- Phoenix Miners
12.13 Ryne Nelson- Arizona Koi
11.15 Ezequiel Tovar- Brooklyn
10.16 Jackson Chourio- Scurvy Dogs
9.5 Brenton Doyle- Windy City
8.11 James Wood- Brooklyn
7.12 Ely De La Cruz- Mother Load Agro
6.17 Jeremy Pena- Phoenix Miners
5.18 Spencer Strider- Moonstruck
4.3 Jordan Westburg- Motor City
3.12 Ryan Pepiot- Scurvy Dogs
2.8 Sal Frelick- Bako
1.16 Reid Detmers- Ann Arbor
Earliest bad pick; 2.1 Kahlil Watson-Brooklyn
2022
10.8 Jared Jones -Pittsburg
8.8 Cole Ragans- Pittsburg
7.8 Dominic Fletcher- Pittsburg
6.6 Spencer Steer-Mother Load Argo
5.4 Zack Thompson- Hawaiian
4.13 Oswaldo Cabrera- Ann Arbor
3.20 Tanner Bibbe - Anecky
2.5 Zach Neto- Brooklyn
1.1 Jackson Holiday- Roxbury
Earliest bad pick- 1.3 Elijah Green- Windy City
2023- Too early to tell!
Jim
Arizona Koi
 

Re: Best player taken per round 2017-2022 minor league drafts

Reply #1 –
Thanks for doing that work and for sharing! It's very cool to see!

Larry - Everest

Re: Best player taken per round 2017-2022 minor league drafts

Reply #2 –
very cool, thanks for doing this!
Craig
Ann Arbor Landlubbers

Re: Best player taken per round 2017-2022 minor league drafts

Reply #3 –
I have 3 of the 5 earliest bad picks...  If you think you're bad at picking...
David
Phoenix Miners

Re: Best player taken per round 2017-2022 minor league drafts

Reply #4 –
Quote from: David Johnson – on
I have 3 of the 5 earliest bad picks...  If you think you're bad at picking...

I don't recall how many times I tried to acquire McKay from you, but it was a lot. I also bought a ton of  rookie baseball cards of his that were not cheap, that are worth jack squat today. I definitely feel like I should take the L on that one as well.
Matt
Mother Lode Argonauts